“Great Lakes Bike Ski Boat is reader supported. We may make a small commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase through links from this site. We get nothing if you don't like what we recommend and return it. Learn more”

The Furling Main Is Quietly Sinking PHRF

Next Saturday morning, coffee in hand, take a slow walk down the main dock at your club. Then count the newer boats with a mainsail rolled up inside the mast. Chances are it’s almost all the newer looking boats from the last 2 decades.

Now walk over to the race committee boat and look at the PHRF entry list for the season. Count how many of those furling-main boats are on it.

I’ll save you the trouble. The answer is close to zero.

That gap, between what’s tied up at the dock and what shows up at the starting line, is the slow leak that is silently sinking handicap racing. It isn’t a scandal or a rule fight. It’s a design decision the industry made around the turn of the century, and we’re only now feeling the full weight of it.

The Boats We’ve Been Buying Since 2000

Somewhere around 2000, in-mast furling went from an option to the default on mainstream production cruisers. Walk any boat show and you’ll see it on Catalinas, Hunters, the Beneteau Oceanis line, the Jeanneau Sun Odysseys, Bavarias and a dozen others. The dealers love it. It sells boats. New boat owners love the idea of not having to raise a main or deal with slab reefing or lazy jacks. It’s an easy marketing sell to inexperienced boaters.

And I understand why. Push a button or pull a line, and the main disappears into the mast. No flaking, no sail cover, no wrestling a wet sail onto the boom while your spouse holds the bow into the wind. For a couple in their fifties buying their first big boat, it removes the single most intimidating chore in sailing. It made cruising more accessible to a lot of people, and that’s a good thing.

But every one of those boats was sold to a buyer who wasn’t thinking about racing. And the boat they bought quietly made sure they never would. In-mast furling quickly proliferated into almost every new 28 to 50 foot sailboat.

Why a Furling Main Can’t Race

A mainsail that rolls up inside a mast has to be flat enough to roll. That one requirement takes away almost everything a racer uses to make a boat go.

  • No roach. The sail’s leech has to be straight or hollow, so you lose the area aft of the line from head to clew, the area that does a lot of the work upwind.
  • No real battens. Vertical battens exist, but most furling mains have none. Without them the leech flutters and the sail can’t hold an efficient shape.
  • Shape baked in, not trimmed in. There’s no cunningham worth the name and outhaul tension is a compromise. Depth is whatever the sailmaker cut and the stretch of the cloth allows.
  • Reefing ruins what shape is left. Partially rolled, the sail gets fuller, not flatter, exactly backwards from what you want when the breeze comes up.
  • Weight and windage aloft. A fat extrusion with a sail rolled inside it is heavy and draggy where it hurts most.

PHRF will hand you a few seconds a mile for all of this. Seconds don’t fix a sail that can’t point, can’t depower, and can’t be tuned. Owners who try it once get buried at the leeward mark, go home, and don’t come back. Most never try at all.

Who’s Actually on the Starting Line

Look at any PHRF fleet in the country and you’ll see two kinds of boats.

The first is the old guard: C&C 30s and 35s, Pearson 10Ms, Catalina 27s and 30s, Tartan 10s, O’Day 34s, Ericsons, Cal 29s, early Hunters and Beneteau First models. Boats from the ’70s, ’80s and ’90s with a conventional main on a boom, slab reefing, and a full set of controls. Most were bought as family cruisers.

Their owners didn’t plan to race either. But one Wednesday a neighbor needed crew, or the club ran a fun race, and the boat could actually compete. A Catalina 30 tall rig made a really competitive PHRF racer with little to no modifications needed and it was affordable too. They could keep up and have fun. One season turned into ten.

The second group is the purpose-built racers and cruiser-racers: J/Boats, Beneteau Firsts, Farr and Melges designs, and the occasional Dehler or X-Yacht. These are great boats. But they’re almost always bought by people who already race and wanted something faster.

The Pipeline Problem

Here’s what most people miss. PHRF was never fed mainly by new racing boats. It was fed by used cruising boats.

A 1984 cruiser went through three, four, maybe five owners. Every one of them had the option of trying a beer can race. Every hand-off was another chance for someone to get hooked. A young couple could buy a tired 30-footer for the price of a used car, show up on a Wednesday night, and be in the game.

The furling-main boat breaks that chain at the first link. The first owner doesn’t race it because it isn’t built to. They aren’t thinking about racing when they bought it. They might try racing for a season before they lose hope. The second owner buys it for the same reasons the first did: easy, comfortable, and roomy. By the time it reaches the third owner at an affordable price, it’s still a boat that can’t race. The door that every old boat held open is welded shut for the life of the hull.

Notice what’s missing: the 2005 Catalina 350, the 2010 Hunter 39, the 2015 Oceanis 41. They’re out there by the hundreds. They just aren’t racing. My dad bought a new Catalina 310 back in 2004 I think. He insisted on the roller furling main. Never raced the boat. The guy who bought the boat from him had almost the same attitude and ideas.

So it isn’t just that a generation of owners hasn’t taken up racing. A generation of boats will never produce racers, no matter who owns them.

The Clock Is Running on the Old Boats

The boats that carry PHRF today are 30, 40, even 50 years old. Fiberglass lasts a long time, but everything bolted to it doesn’t. Balsa cores get wet. Chainplates corrode. Atomic 4s and early diesels give up. Wiring, plumbing, standing rigging, sails: all of it comes due, and usually at the same time. At this point the fiberglass is starting to fatigue as well.

There comes a point where a new engine, a deck recore and a rerig cost more than the boat will ever be worth. That’s when a good old racer gets sold for a dollar, parked behind a shed, or cut up. Every year, more of them cross that line.

When one of those boats leaves the fleet, nothing behind it takes its place. The only replacements are new or late-model performance boats, and those cost real money. Each one usually brings a racer who was already racing. The fleet doesn’t grow. It just gets a little smaller and a little older every season.

So What Do We Do About It?

Nobody is going to talk cruisers out of their furling mains, and nobody should try. What clubs can do is stop pretending those boats belong in the same fleet as a tuned-up J/105.

  • Keep the old boats alive. Clubs that help members find affordable used sails, share tools and swap know-how are protecting the fleet’s real feedstock.
  • Give them an easier handicap based on performance. More seconds per mile if the wind is stronger. These boats can’t reef with any kind of shape or performance.
  • Create a class for dacron sails only. Most of these boats will never see a set of expensive laminate sails, especially not the mains. This would help make other older boats competitive as well for owners who don’t want to participate in the sail buying arms race.
  • There is no easy answer to this. The racers who bought tuned up race boats with new carbon laminate sails don’t want to lose to a Benehuntalina with a flogging roller furling main and won’t be in favor of giving them an easier handicap.

The furling main didn’t kill anybody’s love of sailing. It just quietly stopped turning cruisers into racers. If we want PHRF to be around in twenty years, we have to build a new on-ramp, because the old one is rotting on the hard.

See you on the starting line. Bring your neighbor with the Oceanis or Catalina.

1 thought on “The Furling Main Is Quietly Sinking PHRF”

  1. I bought a 2007 Hunter 33 with a roller furling main. I raced every year that I had the boat but almost always came in last. The PHRF ratings are ridiculously unfair to boats like this. I didn’t really care. I loved that boat..

    Reply

Leave a Comment